A creative illustration of open-loop and closed-loop gift cards, including Amazon, Starbucks, and Target, depicted as paper airplanes flying through the sky. The image represents the versatility of open-loop cards, which can be used anywhere, and the brand-specific nature of closed-loop cards, which encourage customer loyalty.

Open-Loop vs. Closed-Loop Gift Cards: Understanding the Differences and Making the Right Choice

Dren Lubovci

Dren Lubovci

3 min

Gift cards have become a staple in modern gifting, offering convenience and flexibility to both givers and recipients. When I first delved into the world of gift cards, I discovered two primary types: open-loop and closed-loop gift cards. Understanding their differences can help you make informed choices, whether you’re selecting a gift or considering implementing a gift card program for your business.

Open-Loop Gift Cards

Open-loop gift cards are like prepaid debit cards that bear the logo of major payment networks such as Visa, Mastercard, American Express, or Discover. This means they can be used at any merchant that accepts these payment networks, providing recipients with the freedom to spend the card’s value almost anywhere.

Benefits of Open-Loop Gift Cards:

• Versatility: Recipients aren’t limited to a specific store or brand; they can use the card at a wide range of retailers, both online and offline.

• Convenience: These cards are often reloadable and can be used for various purchases, making them similar to cash but with the added security of a card. • Universal Acceptance: Since they’re backed by major payment networks, they’re widely accepted, making them a safe and flexible gifting option.

Closed-Loop Gift Cards:

In contrast, closed-loop gift cards are issued by specific retailers or groups of affiliated merchants. They can only be redeemed at the issuing merchant’s locations or their online store. For example, a Starbucks gift card can only be used at Starbucks outlets.

Benefits of Closed-Loop Gift Cards:

• Brand Loyalty: These cards encourage recipients to shop with the issuing retailer, promoting repeat business and strengthening customer loyalty.

• Customization: Businesses can design these cards to reflect their brand identity, offering a personalized touch that reinforces brand recognition.

Cost-Effective: Typically, closed-loop cards have lower processing fees for merchants compared to open-loop cards, making them a cost-effective option for businesses. 

Choosing Between Open-Loop and Closed-Loop Gift Cards

When deciding between open-loop and closed-loop gift cards, consider the following:

• Recipient’s Preferences: If you’re unsure about the recipient’s favorite stores or want to offer maximum flexibility, an open-loop card might be the better choice.

• Purpose of the Gift: For occasions where a specific experience or product is intended—like a favorite coffee shop or bookstore—a closed-loop card adds a personal touch.

• Business Objectives: For businesses, closed-loop cards can drive customer retention and repeat purchases, while open-loop cards can attract a broader audience by offering more spending options.

A New Perspective on Gift Cards

One aspect that often goes unnoticed is the potential of gift cards in financial inclusion. Open-loop gift cards, for instance, can serve as an introduction to the banking system for unbanked individuals, providing them with a secure and convenient payment method without the need for a traditional bank account. This can be particularly impactful in regions where banking infrastructure is limited.

Implementing Gift Card Programs with Reloadly

For businesses looking to implement or enhance their gift card programs, platforms like Reloadly offer seamless integration of both open-loop and closed-loop gift cards into your services. Reloadly’s API solutions enable businesses to offer digital gift cards, facilitating customer rewards, promotions, and more, thereby enhancing customer engagement and satisfaction.

In conclusion, understanding the nuances between open-loop and closed-loop gift cards allows you to tailor your gifting choices or business strategies effectively. Whether it’s the flexibility of open-loop cards or the brand-specific advantages of closed-loop cards, each serves its purpose in the evolving landscape of consumer preferences and business marketing strategies.

Want to integrate seamless digital gifting into your platform? Explore Reloadly’s powerful API solutions for open-loop and closed-loop gift cards. Visit Reloadly.com to learn more and enhance your digital offerings today or book a Demo today!

This might also interest you:

3 min
Gift cards have revolutionized the way we shop, reward, and engage customers. This article explores the key differences between open-loop and closed-loop gift cards—how open-loop cards offer universal flexibility while closed-loop cards drive brand loyalty. Understanding these distinctions can help businesses and consumers make smarter choices in the evolving digital payments landscape.
4 min
Building a startup is an all-consuming journey—one that requires deep financial knowledge, resilience in fundraising, empathy in leadership, strong sales skills, and a keen eye for hiring. Looking back, there are five things I wish I had known before launching my first company. From understanding cash flow and investor expectations to mastering the art of sales and team-building, these lessons could have saved me time, money, and stress. The early days demand total commitment, often at the cost of work-life balance, but that obsession is what it takes to succeed. If you're embarking on your own founder journey, these insights might just help you navigate the challenges ahead.

Content by developers to developers.

Subscribe to The Monthly Reload for Developers and start receiving all the developers’ updates.

The Monthly Reload: the newsletter for you

Subscribe to our Newsletter and don’t miss any news about our industry and products.

It’s time to build, make your first API call today